Compare
TakeOn vs ProEst.
In short: ProEst is Autodesk's cloud-based construction estimating software, with built-in cost databases (including RSMeans), digital takeoff, bid day analysis of sub quotes, a CRM and a link into Forma Build budgets. If you want general construction cost data like RSMeans behind your estimates, it's the better pick. TakeOn does takeoff and the priced bid in one browser app built for electrical and low-voltage work, with auto-routed homeruns, schedules into takeoff, spec-book questions and MCP. It imports a ProEst Line Item Library, but not assemblies or estimates. ProEst Desktop's sign-in cut-off is December 31, 2026 at the latest.
ProEst and TakeOn both run online, both take off quantities from the drawings into the estimate, both build estimates from assemblies, and both compare the quotes that come in on bid day. Both let a team work from one shared set of estimates.
ProEst is ahead on data and on the business around the bid. Autodesk offers four ways to fill its cost database: import your own, start from a built-in one, use the ProEst Costbook of more than 23,000 lines of regional costs, or use RSMeans. It adds a CRM, conceptual reporting from past bids, an open API, and estimates that convert into Forma Build budgets. TakeOn has no pre-loaded database, price feed or accounting tie-in: you keep your own material catalog and labor hours.
TakeOn differs in what it does with an electrical drawing. Find Similar counts a symbol across the sheet, Route to… draws a homerun to its panel around keep-out zones, a panel or fixture schedule boxed on the sheet becomes takeoff, and a spec book answers a plain-language question with the pages it came from. Claude, ChatGPT or any MCP client can read and work your takeoff and priced bid. The table below says where each one stands.
What happens to ProEst Desktop?
ProEst Desktop stops working at the end of your current subscription term or on December 31, 2026, whichever comes first, when Autodesk turns off desktop authentication. Autodesk's path for Desktop customers is ProEst in the cloud, the product this page compares. If your renewal date is before December 31, that's your real deadline.
If you're weighing a switch instead, your Line Item Library can come with you. On TakeOn's Materials page, Import (ProEst / CSV) reads a ProEst or Forma Line Item Library export into the material catalog: the WBS code becomes a cost code, labor productivity becomes labor hours per unit, and a re-import updates items by Part number. Assemblies and estimates don't import yet, so rebuild the assemblies you use most and finish open bids in ProEst. Our post on ProEst Desktop's end of life and your options walks through each path.
Feature comparison
How does TakeOn compare to ProEst?
Platform
| Feature | TakeOn | ProEst |
|---|---|---|
| Runs in a browser | Yes — nothing to install | Yes — Autodesk sells ProEst as cloud-based (ProEst Desktop's sign-in cut-off is Dec 31, 2026 at the latest) |
| Runs on a Mac | Yes — Safari, Chrome, Edge, Firefox | Autodesk's ProEst page doesn't list requirements; check with Autodesk |
| Several people on the same job | Yes — live cursors, simultaneous edit on the same plan | Yes — online access so the team shares estimates and project data in one place |
| Built for | Electrical and low-voltage contractors | Construction estimating in general; Autodesk's page names no one trade |
Cost data
| Feature | TakeOn | ProEst |
|---|---|---|
| A pre-loaded cost database | No — you keep a workspace material catalog | Yes — built-in databases, the ProEst Costbook (23,000+ lines of regional costs), or RSMeans |
| Import a cost database you already have | Yes — a ProEst or Forma Line Item Library export, or any CSV or Excel price list | Yes — import the data from your legacy system |
| Assemblies (kits) that expand into priced parts | Yes — plus a starter library of common electrical kits, priced blank | Yes — assemblies generated from formula variables |
Takeoff
| Feature | TakeOn | ProEst |
|---|---|---|
| Takeoff from the plans, feeding the estimate | Yes — on PDF plans; counts, runs and areas priced in the same project | Yes — digital takeoff that calculates labor and material costs; Autodesk's page doesn't say which plan files it reads |
| Automatic symbol counting | Yes — Find Similar: drag once on a sheet, review and stamp the matches | Not on Autodesk's ProEst page that we can find |
| Homeruns | Yes — auto-routed to the panel around keep-out zones, across match lines and floors | Not on Autodesk's ProEst page that we can find |
Electrical depth
| Feature | TakeOn | ProEst |
|---|---|---|
| Panel and fixture schedules captured into takeoff | Yes — box the table, map columns, stamp counts | Not on Autodesk's ProEst page that we can find |
| Ask the spec book a question | Yes — plain-language answers that cite the exact pages | Not on Autodesk's ProEst page that we can find |
| Connect an AI assistant (MCP) | Yes — Claude, ChatGPT or any MCP client, scoped and revocable | Not on Autodesk's ProEst page that we can find; ProEst has an open API for integrations |
Estimating and the bid
| Feature | TakeOn | ProEst |
|---|---|---|
| Compare sub and vendor quotes | Yes — Pre-bid scopes go out for pricing and quotes are leveled side by side | Yes — Bid Day Analysis compares subcontractor costs, margins and exclusions |
| What you send the client | A branded proposal PDF and takeoff report, plus CSV or Excel exports | Reports from a library of pre-designed templates |
| Bids and clients | Pipeline stage, estimator and customer records on each project, and a bid calendar | Yes — online bid management plus a built-in CRM |
| Historical and budget data | No — no conceptual estimates from past bids, no accounting integration | Yes — conceptual reporting from past bids; estimates convert to Forma Build budgets; accounting integrations |
When should you stay on ProEst?
Stay if you estimate more than electrical and low-voltage work in one tool. ProEst is general construction estimating, with RSMeans and a regional Costbook behind it; TakeOn is built for two trades.
Stay, too, if your ProEst assemblies are the asset, and there's no time to rebuild them. TakeOn imports the Line Item Library, not assemblies. And stay if your company runs on Autodesk Forma and wants estimates to flow into Forma Build budgets, or relies on ProEst's CRM and history of past bids. Moving from Desktop to the cloud version is the path Autodesk itself supports.
Consider TakeOn if your bids are electrical or low voltage, and the hours go into counting devices, measuring homeruns and reading schedules and spec books. Import your Line Item Library, run your next new bid in TakeOn next to ProEst, and compare.
Switching questions
Common questions from ProEst users.
Can't find an answer? Email contact@takeonbid.com — we read every one.
-
Is ProEst being discontinued?
ProEst Desktop is. Autodesk turns off its sign-in at the end of your current subscription term or on December 31, 2026, whichever comes first. ProEst itself carries on as Autodesk's cloud-based estimating product, and it's the path Autodesk names for Desktop customers. This page compares TakeOn with that cloud product.
-
Can I import my ProEst cost database into TakeOn?
Yes, the Line Item Library. TakeOn's Materials page imports a ProEst or Forma Line Item Library export into its material catalog: the WBS code becomes a cost code, labor productivity becomes labor hours per unit, and a re-import updates items by Part number instead of duplicating them. ProEst assemblies and estimates don't import, so you rebuild the assemblies you use most and finish open bids in ProEst.
-
Does TakeOn come with a cost database like ProEst?
No. ProEst offers built-in databases, its ProEst Costbook of more than 23,000 lines of regional costing data, and RSMeans. TakeOn has no pre-loaded database or pricing-service feed. You keep a workspace material catalog, imported from a ProEst export or your supplier's CSV or Excel price list, plus a starter library of common electrical kits priced blank.
-
What does TakeOn do that ProEst doesn't?
As far as we can tell from Autodesk's ProEst page: counting a symbol across a sheet automatically, routing homeruns to the panel, capturing panel and fixture schedules into the takeoff, asking a spec book a question with page citations, and connecting an AI assistant such as Claude over MCP. TakeOn is also built for electrical and low-voltage work only, where ProEst covers construction estimating in general. Check Autodesk's current pages if one of these matters to you.
-
Is Forma Estimate the same as ProEst?
No. Forma Estimate is a separate Autodesk estimating product in Autodesk Forma, which Autodesk sells alongside ProEst under Forma for Preconstruction. Autodesk publishes its own comparison of the two. This page compares TakeOn with ProEst only.
Sources
ProEst product facts come from Autodesk's ProEst page and Quick Start course, read October 2026. The Desktop cut-off and the Forma Estimate comparison follow Autodesk's end-of-life FAQ and comparison posts as quoted in search results; we couldn't load those two pages directly. Check the current pages before deciding.
- Autodesk: ProEst construction estimating software (cloud-based; cost databases, Costbook and RSMeans; digital takeoff; bid day analysis; bid management; CRM; reporting; integrations; Forma Build budgets)
- Autodesk Learning: ProEst Quick Start (assemblies from formula variables, the import template)
- Autodesk: ProEst Desktop end-of-life FAQ
- Autodesk: Forma Estimate vs. ProEst
- Autodesk Forma: products (ProEst and Forma Estimate under Forma for Preconstruction)
See it for yourself
See it on your next bid.
Run a real electrical takeoff in the browser today, no credit card needed. Keep ProEst open while you compare.